No-cull bovine TB policy condemned

6:39am Wednesday 23rd July 2008

The Government's policy for dealing with tuberculosis in cattle is "not good enough" and fails to recognise the seriousness of the situation, MPs have said.

The Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Efra) Committee said it was "extremely disappointed" with the Government's "tentative" response to its report into badgers and TB in cattle - in which it said culling badgers could make a contribution to tackling the disease.

The committee said there was little in the Government's strategy, beyond the existing policy of surveillance, testing and slaughter, to address the problem in the short term.

"This is not good enough - it fails to recognise fully the seriousness of the situation," they said.

Earlier this month, Environment Secretary Hilary Benn ruled out giving farmers licences to cull, in a move backed by wildlife groups but condemned by farmers.

The decision was made after the Efra committee published its report into badgers and cattle TB in which it said that in certain circumstances a cull could help reduce the disease in badly-hit areas.

The MPs acknowledged culling badgers - which can spread the disease to cattle - alone would not be a universal solution to TB in herds. They also urged the Government to ensure that it paid fair compensation for cattle slaughtered after testing positive for TB.

The committee's chairman Michael Jack said: "The committee unanimously felt that the response by the Secretary of State was less than satisfactory and that certain key deficiencies in it should be highlighted."

A Defra spokeswoman said: "We will study the committee's detailed comments and respond in due course."

Editor's Choice